Kelly has an unbelievable knack to take something that is fairly complex and provide an easy-to-digest perspective on it. Both Sean & Tim noticed this throughout their conversation with her. As an accomplished entrepreneur and speaker, Kelly's company (Agency Performance Partners) has been inspiring insurance agency owners for more than a decade. In this ep, she gives her own insightful opinion as to why the insurance industry has shifted to a hard market, and how "crispy" some of the loyal, hard-working insurance agency employees have become. Don't sleep on this one, it's awesome!
Our goal with Bricks & Risk is that you walk away with 1 or 2 valuable nuggets that can help build your own business. Our audience grows through word of mouth, so if you would please take a moment of your time and give us a review on the platform you’re on, that would be fantastic!
Please also help spread the B&R word by sharing your favorite episode with a friend. You can find all B&R episodes on Spotify, Apple Music, YouTube, and anywhere else you get your podcast content. We greatly appreciate your time and trust.
Until next week, keep learning and keep growing!
** Episode Shout-Outs **
→ Bentley University, Go Falcons: https://www.bentley.edu/
→ Sponsor, Property Management Redefined: https://gopmr.com/
📲 Contact Info 📲
→ Sean Mooney, Mooney Insurance Brokers: www.mooneybrokers.com/
→ Tim Garrity, The Tim Garrity Team: www.timgarrityteam.com/
💥 Watch us on YouTube 💥
→ YouTube, Bricks & Risk Podcast, @bricksandrisk: www.youtube.com/@BricksandRisk/?sub_confirmation=1
💥 Follow us on Social Media 💥
→ Instagram, Bricks & Risk Podcast, @bricksandrisk: https://www.instagram.com/bricksandrisk/
→ Instagram, Sean Mooney, @sean.moonee: https://www.instagram.com/sean.moonee/@sean.moonee
→ Instagram, Tim Garrity, @realestateinphl: https://www.instagram.com/realestateinphl/
→ Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/bricksandrisk
→ LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/bricksandrisk
One of our clients had a policy non renewed because or canceled after writing it because they had five bags of mulch in the driveway. Yes. And I was like, well, wouldn't this be like they're taking care of their home? They're doing gardening. Like no one's and I was like, if somebody fell, wouldn't it be better for them to fall on mulch than it would be to for them to fall on the concrete? Like, but no, it was like, nope, there, that's uh, that's debris in the driveway. Debris there was no negotiation. And we everyone had like their their their fire, their uh patio furniture was too close to the fire pit. And I was like, so can't they just move it? Like the fire pit wasn't on. It wasn't on. Like somebody could have just been reading a book out there, putting their like feet up on the fire pit just to like relax. And they're like, nope, too close to the fire pit. I'm like, well, now we're just we're being ridiculous.
SPEAKER_01Welcome to the podcast dedicated to real estate, insurance, and building your business. Join us as we take you along our own business building journeys with additional wisdom from our network of local and national experts. Welcome to Bricks and Risk.
SPEAKER_02This episode is brought to you by Property Management Redefined. PMR is not just managing properties, we're creating partnerships that build long-term success for property owners. John and his team can be reached at manage at gopmr.com or by phone 267 753 6005. Tim. Yes, Sean. Who's a good client for PMR?
SPEAKER_01Property management redefined is looking for property owners who value three things accountability, reliability, and a results-driven approach. You want to maximize returns, but still provide client and tenant satisfaction.
SPEAKER_00There's a lot of property managers out there. What does PMR do really well?
SPEAKER_01Biggest thing is they're seamless and they're worry-free. So with that approach in mind, it allows the property owner to put their trust in PMR and know that the results will be there. The other thing I think a property owner is really gonna value because they do it so well is that they have a local expert team boots on the ground, managing your properties and your tenants' expectations every day so that you feel good about your investments.
SPEAKER_00We have millions of listeners out there. Tens of millions. If they want more information, how do they find PMR?
SPEAKER_01Right here, guys, reach out to John Sachs and his team at Property Management Redefine. Take good care of you. Hey everyone, welcome to another episode of Bricks and Risk. I'm Tim Garrety. And I'm Sean Mooney. Today's Sean, we have another out-of-state guest, an insurance expert, the chief BFF officer at Agency Performance Partners. We have Kelly Donahue Piero. How are you doing today, Kelly?
SPEAKER_05I am doing great. And you know what's funny? You say I'm out of state, but I travel every week. So you never know where I might be. Oh never know.
SPEAKER_01That's a fair point. I did not know that. Thanks for letting me know. So, coming out of Warwick, Rhode Island, she is founder and president of insurance consulting and training firm Agency Performance Partners. Kelly has been inspiring clients and conference attendees alike to be ridiculously amazing for more than a decade. An empathetic visionary, Kelly sees herself and her team not just as expert advisors, but as a BFF to agency owners, coming alongside with an arm around the shoulder when times are tough, and a round of high fives when success rolls in. Kelly's professional journey began with a degree in relationship marketing from Bentley University in 2003, and she hasn't hit pause since, serving, among other roles, as vice president of client services for an insurance digital marketing firm, once named one of America's fastest growing companies by Inc. magazine. Since 2014, she has helmed agency performance partners and traveled to U.S. and Canada as a highly sought-after speaker, empowering insurance agents to face change with a can-do attitude and a growth mindset. Her specialties include consulting and coaching on upselling, account rounding, agency culture change, sales scripting, executive level coaching, benchmarking, and agency retention skills. Super impressive. Did we get it all, Kelly? Yeah, did we?
SPEAKER_05It's so awkward to hear your own bio read by the window. I have to say it's it's like hopefully I did a half decent job. You did a great job. But when we public speak, it's like you're in the wings and you're like, okay. Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_01When are we getting to it?
SPEAKER_04Yeah.
SPEAKER_05Like that's it, but I get it, you know, and it's uh I don't know. I tend to make it more about the clients than about me. So it's always a a bit awkward. So if you see me, that there you go, you made me blush for the first time in the podcast.
SPEAKER_02Woo-hoo! And also, too, Kelly, uh a lot so we have insurance and real estate. So there's a lot of people out there really uh real estate involved that you know need the better understanding of kind of well for those real estate friends, I did do a short stint in mortgages.
SPEAKER_05So yes, I can I can speak that love language. And I started my career in banking, which had some of the the real estate side attached. So all of it's uh like it's all an ecosystem.
SPEAKER_01Yep. Might have to dive into that. So all right, so as I've been hearing from my friend Sean here for almost the last two years since we started recording the show, is that the insurance market has shifted in a minor way. Right, right. Very small. Um, and from what I've also heard, it's shifted into a hard market. So with that in mind, how can insurance agencies re-strategize for growth in this hard market?
SPEAKER_05Well, it's also impacting you guys on the real estate side, right? So harder to get insurance, harder to qualify. Lit the, you know, the buildings have to be pristine in nature. Uh so yes, it's impacting the whole ecosystem. So what we're seeing though across the you know, United States is we're many markets are starting to shift out of the hard market, very baby steps, right? Not um not dramatic. Yeah, I will say this if you're in Georgia, Texas, California, you are still uh battling. Congratulations, you'll be here for another year for different reasons um, you know, for each of those states. But uh, we're starting to see promise. Like rates are stabilizing, carrier appetite has gotten a little better, just a tad, a teeny tiny tad bit better. So, where what how I would answer this question is, you know, there's three buckets agencies need to focus on as we move out of it. I think everybody's thinking the hard market, party on, like it's gonna leave and we can go back to normal. It will not. I'm sad to say this to everybody. The good news is your rates won't go backwards, although Florida auto is starting to go soft. So Florida auto is dropping nine to ten percent. So imagine making nine to ten percent less um to do the same amount of work. Um, but we don't predict that in other parts of the country. So a couple of things. One, you need to focus on retaining customers because here's what happened in the hard market that you've heard about. Your clients shopped. When they shopped, they found there was nothing better. Um it was kind of like stay still, digest the rate. Perfect. The problem is they got out all out into these other people's systems. So now when the market shifts, you are silly to think that those companies like State Farm or even other independent agents aren't gonna be attacking your customer.
SPEAKER_04Right.
SPEAKER_05You're not proactive in contacting them and reaching out and trying to cross-sell them and offer them reviews and potentially proactively with reason remarket to core carriers that are gonna have a mutually beneficial relationship, you will start losing. So we always play this rate game in insurance, which is silly. Um, so when the rates stabilize, people will try to relax, and that's actually time you're gonna need to put some rocket fuel in the tank and level up.
SPEAKER_02Wow.
SPEAKER_05Your book's gonna be under attack and there will be market to go to.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, you know what, Kellyanne, I can speak to that uh firsthand as when when the rates were taking the ginormous increases over the last year or two, we didn't get um we didn't get as much uh activity or clients reaching out to us. We're seeing it now more than ever where they're saying, hey, this went up 10 or 15%. For some reason, I can't explain it. Maybe there's something behind it. Um but if we're basing it just on an activity level from uh the customer end, those for us and our agency are up.
SPEAKER_05Yeah. Well, and and I think that the the idea is to me, we have to earn our renewal commission.
SPEAKER_04Yep.
SPEAKER_05There's a lot of agencies, oh that that auto renews, or we're so busy, we're so busy, but you're busy on the wrong customers, which leads me to my second point. Agencies need to become efficient and effective. So um, we need to have tech savvy teams, we need headsets, we need first call resolution, you need to embrace technology, and you need to fire the bottom 10 to 15% of your customers that are draining your resources. That's scary to a lot of people, right? Um, but you can't this this is how I use it to insurance agencies. My brother sometimes has insurance, okay? Maybe we all have a brother out there like that. Or at least a second cousin.
SPEAKER_01Right, right, right. Sometimes I have it for sometimes I don't.
SPEAKER_05Yeah. So I say he has half a policy, right? But I have 28 policies between commercial, life, you know, personal. 28. So in theory, in an agency, I should get 28 units of service every year.
SPEAKER_04Yeah.
SPEAKER_05My brother should get half. But do you know who eats up my service?
SPEAKER_02Half.
SPEAKER_05My brother. Because you're gonna tell him to pay, remind him to pay.
SPEAKER_00He's gonna call scrambling because then they're more.
SPEAKER_05I need to go do it. You're gonna go back and forth. My mom's gonna end up paying. It's gonna be absolute freaking chaos for somebody who's gonna lapse and cancel again or get into an accident with a 20-year-old vehicle and stomp to all high heaven when you total his car.
SPEAKER_01Right. I think uh what I find so interesting about just your your comment on retention as like advice in this market is that kind of like the underlying foundation of our podcast has been built on relationships and business. And and the relationships and business, they also come from the relationships in your life. If you live your life in a good way where you value friends and family and neighbors and parents at your kids' school, and coaches on your kids' team, or whatever, other dog owners, other cat owners, like you just look at it differently. And I think retention is probably not what a lot of people are thinking right now if their insurance business is really hurting it. Like, this happens in real estate too. When real estate slowed down two years ago, when the interest rates went up and prices were too high, this happened all across the country. Yeah, sales went down 30%. So, what I started preaching, especially through the show, is like take care of the people you know, not the people you don't know, because the people you know need you now more than ever. They need to understand that they're the value of their home is okay, or like the sky's not falling down, or would you like to fix up your bathroom and increase the value of your asset in this down mark? Whatever it is, you're just helping them. And that retention is really what shores your business up for when it does go back the other way, and everyone's still right there, and you were with them through the hard times. So I think that's fantastic advice.
SPEAKER_05Well, it is, but here's the other problem that you have a little bit in insurance. We have a very burned-out team. They're crispy. Like if you look at them, they might disintegrate into ash in front of you.
SPEAKER_01Yes, crispy. Don't touch the shoulder.
SPEAKER_05Do not touch the shoulder. Like, because you know, service people are love sweethearts. They want to love people, they want to help them. And there has been no way to help. You have to have a lot of difficult conversations. So, like we even swapped some salespeople and insurance agencies to the save team and saying you're gonna be now incentivized to save cancellations. Because the service team, you know, if I came and said, Hey, you know what? I I've saved $200 in my insurance, you guys have been great, but $200, they'll be like, I understand. $200 is a lot of money. That makes sense. Let me get you over to State Farm.
SPEAKER_04Right.
SPEAKER_05You know, because they're like, Oh, I'm you know, I tried, but they're just they're saving money. Like, yeah, so um, you have these very crispy people because they're having these hard conversations day after day after day, and it's so far out of their personality zone where they just want to love people and help them and help them get an auto ID card and take their payment and be happy. And now we've just completely like turned them into a prison gang of like, if I get arrested, I'm gonna join the personal lines account manager gang in prison because they will change here. Like they got cut off jean jackets with big patches on the back together and they are like, yeah, no. Um, and that's because their battery's so low. So we also, I think, as part of that being, you know, figuring out retention is we have to figure out how to rebuild them, rebuild their confidence, rebuild their skills, rebuild, you know, what is the right thing to do because they've just been, you know, mopped up for the past few years. A lot of them are working moms, so they homeschooled their kid and then all of a sudden they went into a hard market and there was not 10 minutes in between all of this. So we have a team that really does need to be built back up. And I think leadership is going to become so critical, which is why I believe we have to become this efficient and effective agency. And, you know, there's about 12 things you can do to be efficient. And I think a lot of agencies never pay attention to this focus. So everybody says, we need more people, we need more people. But when you look at the industry average, you're overstaffed but still backlogged. So there's a gap in there about 12 things that you know you can utilize, whether it's your processes are bloated, you're not using technology. Um, but if you want to become efficient, because you're gonna have to defend your customers, and that leads me to three, which is there's gonna be more shopping in the marketplace too. So if I can defend and I have enough bandwidth to sell, which means you need a good sales process, you need to have high standards, you need to have a repeatable sales process and insurance that you can whip quick and get them sold and cross-sold and you know, not just sell them on a line. Like a lot of agencies have a quoting process, they don't have a sales experience. So if you can rack your sales experience, you can be efficient and you can rack retention, you can put rocket fuel into your agency over the next couple years. If you are still churning, like you're losing one and selling one, you're circling the drain, and that's because you don't have a strategy. You're sort of just trying your best every day with the tools that you have.
SPEAKER_01Hey everyone, this is Tim, your favorite bricks and risk co-host. But don't tell Sean. I hope you're enjoying this episode, and I'll get right back to it in a moment. Our audience grows through word of mouth, so if you would please take a moment of your time and give us a review on the platform you're on, that would be fantastic. Please also help spread the BR word by sharing your favorite episode with a friend. We greatly appreciate your time and trust. Now, back to the show. First thing. All right. So here's here's another question for you. So we're talking about how the market has shifted. Employees are crispy, customer service.
SPEAKER_05So crispy, crispy.
SPEAKER_01Why do you like in your own eyes? Like, what are some of the main reasons why the market has shifted to where it is today? I mean, this guy talks about it all the time. I'd love to hear your perspective.
SPEAKER_05I'll tell you my favorite. I mean, I'm sure he's said a million ones, like, I don't my favorite the way it was explained to me, and it made so much sense to me, is it I mean, there's obviously several components, but one of them is I don't know about your grandparents, but my grandparents had like this incredible sense of pride of paying off their mortgage, right? Like my dad and his two brothers grew up in like a you know a 900 square foot house with a mom, a dad, and three boys.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Chaos. That's like that's like a turf war.
SPEAKER_05Yeah. My grandfather got out of the military, saved up every penny, purchased a house. They lived in the same house, right? Like even when my grandmother had to be moved into a nursing home or, you know, or assisted living, it was like, well, what about the house? And it's like, grandma, this house is like, you know, there's like crooked floors, like you're going to fall. There's stairs everywhere. It's like an old house, right? Yeah. Well, that was the way things worked. Today things are so different. People don't stay, there's not the same pride of owning your house outright, right? Like there is not the same maintenance budget for houses. So if you ask your friends how old's your roof, how many of them do you think know?
SPEAKER_00Probably not.
SPEAKER_05They wait until the roof leaks and then says, I need a new roof. Right.
SPEAKER_00Yep.
SPEAKER_05And you know, you take the advent of social media or you're, you know, texting your friends, look at my new kitchen, my granite countertops. And instead, maybe the next budget goes into the new bathroom with marble versus the new roof.
SPEAKER_04Yeah.
SPEAKER_05So economics have shifted. And or if you're planning on like, hey, we're gonna, we need to get into the school system because our child has to go to the best school system.
SPEAKER_04Right.
SPEAKER_05We're gonna sell our house and we're not gonna do all this maintenance to it because we're gonna sell it and come to the top of our budget in a new house that also might have a 17-year-old roof. And we're not thinking about the $30,000 that needs to get spent on it. So insurance turned into home maintenance policies in a large Oh wow.
SPEAKER_01Wow, interesting.
SPEAKER_05And you know, that became where like think about it, your grandparents. Oh, it's time to do the windows. Yeah. These windows last you have 20 years and it is year 19.
SPEAKER_01No, you're you're so right. Like in my industry, so so I I'm also part of a development team.
SPEAKER_05You love it when people put the granite countertops in. Oh, yeah. Absolutely.
SPEAKER_01I get to say stone countertops in the MLS description. Yeah. But uh, but no, it's funny you say this. So, like, um, so it it I help clients buy, sell, rent, lease real estate, invest, but we invest ourselves. We have a development team, so we flip homes, we hold some homes, and we've we've reimagined some buildings. And I I've taken either first-time home buyers or our own development team through these old properties in Philadelphia, and it's like it's had the same owner for like 30, 40 years. And we I'm like, let's start in the basement. And we start in the basement, I'm like, look, the electrical panel has been replaced. Look at look at the wires coming out, they look good. Or like they re they redid the fort or they parged the walls, or like the HVAC system is only five years old, or I'm going to all the rooms. Look, the windows are new here, like and and the roof has been coated again. It's a row home, it's got a rubber roof, it's only five years old. Like, today's buyer doesn't see that. What they see is they see, does it have a nice kitchen? Does it have a nice floor color? Exactly. It's all about taste and style. And I say it all the time. I'm like, you know, almost like like a grand grandmother grandfather special. Those are the homes you want because they took care of the things that mattered to the home, not the tiny little details that matter. Like the appliances are still green because they work, and they're like, why would we get rid of them?
SPEAKER_05Like we clearly like the ones say where it's like you get like six, seven years. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Oh, now you get you pay you pay 10 times what they paid, and then it falls apart in two years. It's that's unbelievable. It's very interesting that that you say that.
SPEAKER_05No, it that's a big, that's a big, big piece of it, right? And then the you know, you you the other piece that is just true is society has changed, right? So when there's a hail storm, there's 700 roofing contractors saying, Oh, that that's damaged. We're gonna get you a new roof, and they encourage claims, right? Right. Um, or everybody gets into a car accident and wants to sue for 10 grand of pain and suffering. Well, somebody pays for that at some point. Right. It's not, you know, they settle it because it economically it's less expensive, but we all pay for that, you know? Um, so there's a lot of reasons why the hard market hit. You know, to me, also the carriers had a little hand in it of their underwriting guidelines were too loose. They allowed it too. This was no different than the mortgage situation in 2008.
SPEAKER_04Yep.
SPEAKER_05Lending allowed it. Wall Street wanted it. All of it got created, and then it became, you know, the slap across the face. You couldn't operate that way any longer. Um, so I, you know, there's there's a lot of reasons, but I also tell everybody whether it's mortgage, real estate, insurance, our job as leaders is to strategize. We are here to solve problems. You're not gonna be handed the same market every single day. So you have to get out of your own way and say, what's the game plan? You're the coach, you're the leader. You have to tell your team the plan.
SPEAKER_02Well, it's very important. And going back to your previous point, Kelly, about the crispy employee, I I gotta go a little further than that because Are you envisioning one right now? Well, here, let me give you the scenario. The other day, uh, and this this is a microcosm of what's going on. Um we had a renewal account, they did a renewal inspection, they went out, took a photo, did the inspection, turn it back. Hey, you need to remove this tree from the house. It's leaning on the house. Pull it up, send it to the client. Client says, That's not my house. Whoa. I said, Okay, but in the report here, I see your address on the thing. He goes, That's the same number, but that's not my house. Pull it up. I pull it up on Google, that's not the house. Send it back to underwriter. It's not the house. Can you can you delete this? Um Um note uh from the tree. It's not his not his property, not his tree. Uh no, I can't do that because the inspection company found that this tree is there. Oh wow.
SPEAKER_05Wait, but they did it wrong. No, they did it wrong. Right?
SPEAKER_02So no one's gonna accept blame. Hold that. So I go, I go, oh man, to your point, Kelly. We have to be problem solvers. I say, all right, let me find this house. As the internet sleuth that I am. You are I found the house.
SPEAKER_05Which which by the way, like anybody could have done like just a quick called Google Maps.
SPEAKER_02No, no, no. Street view. No, no, no, no. It was the same number, but that was it didn't have the street. There was no way to identify the house with this. Okay. So I had to like search through the whole like we did advanced ninja skills. I had to go to the whole town, find these. So then I I I send this back. Say, hey, found the house. It's not the house, the house is over here. Can you resend uh the notice from underwriting? Crickets. Just going back and forth with the underwriting. The next day notice of non-renewal comes out. This was yesterday. I sent to my underwriter. And I'm like, what are we doing here? Now my client thinks that we're idiots, right? Because they inspected the wrong house. Now he's getting a letter of non-renewal because of the person who did the the they paid the person, the carrier paid the person to go inspect the house, they inspect the wrong house. Now the the client's gonna get a letter from his insurance company saying we're not renewing your house because of that tree. Oh my god. That's not my tree. This is what's going on. I mean, I could give you a thousand of these scenarios. When you say our employees are crispy, it's because of this.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_02It's because they have to navigate these scenarios, and every day it's a new scenario.
SPEAKER_05And you're like, what it's also it's it's also like making your job irrevolution like harder. It's you know, it's the drone inspection. Yes, all of it. It's like we had, you know, at the hard market, the height of it, I we had somebody, one of our clients had a policy non-renewed because or canceled after writing it because they had five bags of mulch in the driveway. Yes. And I was like, What? Well, wouldn't this be like they're taking care of their home, they're doing gardening? Like no one's and I was like, if somebody fell, wouldn't it be better for them to fall on mulch than it would be to for them to fall on the concrete? Like, but no, it was like, nope, there that's uh that's debris in the driveway. Debris and there was no negotiation. And we ever had like their their their fire their uh patio furniture was too close to the fire pit. And I was like, so can't they just move it? Like the fire pit wasn't on. It wasn't on. Like somebody could have just been reading a book out there, putting their like feet up on the fire pit just to like relax. They're like, nope, too close to the fire pit. And like so.
SPEAKER_02So yes, we have rate, yes, we have eligibility issues that we're dealing with, but then it's like these mini grenades get lobbed into our laps every single day. And our employees are like, oh my God, I can't take it anymore. Like, this is like driving me bananas.
SPEAKER_05And you then on top of it, all you add in that at one point in time, the underage would get back to you like in a reasonable amount of time. Now you lob that over and it's three, four, five, out of office, or they're not with a carrier.
SPEAKER_02I said to a carrier the other day, I said, I don't know how you guys do it. I said, it's like trying to straighten uh the chairs on the deck of the Titanic. Because I literally talk to a different underwriter like every month. Every month, every month it's like, no, this person's now your underwriter, and then this person, you so you can't, you don't have a rapport, you don't have a relationship with your underwriter anymore. That's gone.
SPEAKER_05So they don't they don't want that any longer.
SPEAKER_01Do you think this is, I mean, is is a lot of this stemming from um the fact that the business is hard right now, the industry is hard, profits are down, so they're cutting staff or or people are just burnt out and they're missing like what is causing all that?
SPEAKER_05It's so it's a couple fold. Um, one, the underwriters, the the the encouragement before was build relationships with your agencies, right? So then all these new rules came down. When people are involved in making decisions, we are influenced by humanity, right? So they had to write letter, they had to they had to write letter of the law. And that was their directive. So before it was growth, grow, develop, work hard to try to get it done. Now it's like literally the music died and it was like a screeching halt, right? So you have this underwriting shift where they had to start telling people no, and people, you know, people are prone to make exceptions. So they would like to stop and just go, and and the big problem was there was no reinsurance available, like reinsurance dried. So they're on the hook personally for all these, which is why they stopped. So when when reinsurance, we like to say America was like the drunk driver that they were trying to insure. Like we were, we had all these storms, it was wild, we had all these competing factors. So reinsurance is like peace. I'm not backing you up.
SPEAKER_04Yeah.
SPEAKER_05No, you guys let it go too wild. So now these insurance, they have to be on the hook in order for them to keep their rating, you know, because carriers would get downgraded during this too. So in order to keep your rating, you you had to go write letter of the law. So they are more inclined to load them up so people can't have these one-on-one. Please just do me a favor, please just do me a favor.
SPEAKER_04Gotcha.
SPEAKER_05The other half is you have a lot of people just getting out of the business, right? Again, silver tsunami, where get a lot of people retiring out. So your veteran underwriters, they were like, I'm out during COVID. I can just hang out with my grandkids. I don't need this. Bye. So there's a staffing gap for sure. And, you know, they're gonna try to use AI. Like, who's if if you are running these big companies privately backed, they're gonna try to use AI to do underwriting. So it's it's, you know, I I think we're probably up against this in a lot of industries, right? I'm sure you see it in the lending side too, right? They're gonna use AI to help underwrite mortgages. Um, they're not just gonna go on your handwritten application so much anymore.
SPEAKER_02Right. Well, in addition to that, Kelly, I think that it's um there's been no time in history recently where people leave and it's it there's no tenure with uh employers anymore. Correct. Right? It's like I'm I go make more money here, boom, I'm out. Right. So and the recruiters are fierce too. Yeah, it just that's fuel on the fire as to like go over here, show me more money. Yep.
SPEAKER_05Well, and another thing that happened, we we dealt with some carriers, like you know, COVID hits, everybody works from home, but this causes some challenges. I'm sure you experience like underwriters don't pick up the phone. Yeah, they don't email you, they email you back, they won't call you. Yeah, so like the underwriters were kind of like hiding out because they were so short-staffed, the carriers couldn't really hold them accountable to service standards either. So they some carriers were like, hey, we need to call people back in the office. Like, this is getting untenable of a situation. And so then the underwriters that really liked working from home, staying incognito, the recruiters would find them another work from home underwriting job.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. And that's leverage. It's like, well, give me this or I'm going. Huh?
SPEAKER_05Correct.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_05Correct. I mean, we had a whole carrier where I had to write help them write a policy on acceptable athletic leisure wear to return to the office. Because one of the things that all the staff was upset about was having to put pants back on again.
SPEAKER_02That's real.
SPEAKER_05And I was like, I was like, okay. Uh like I suppose. What is acceptable? Like, if that's your biggest challenge, like who comes into the office? Like, I don't, I'm not dress code aside. I think you dress for however you feel comfortable. But if you're in a professional environment, you might need to put pants with a button on.
SPEAKER_04Yep.
SPEAKER_05But if that's what's gonna get everybody to come back to the office and serve the agencies a little bit better, we will talk about appropriate joggers.
SPEAKER_01We'll talk about elastic if that's what makes sense to you. That's where we're that's where we've come to. All right. So here's a question. So we asked, pick one of three topics. Our three topics are email, marketing, hiring, and staffing, or routine. You picked routine. So my question is, how does your routine lead to success in business?
SPEAKER_05So this is funny because a couple of months ago I posted on social media like my morning routine. And it we're hiring for new candidates, and people are like, I checked out your morning routine posts. Because I got like a little fraction.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_05Um, so I am a huge believer of how you start your day leads to everything else. Um, I'll I'll mine is mine is always gets some um shocks, but I wake up at 3 45 every morning.
SPEAKER_01Whoa, that's the earliest I've ever heard. So super impressive.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, I I do it pretty consistently because every now and again I take a weekend off if like I've been traveling a lot and I need to catch up on sleep. But I just like the morning to be quiet. I don't like to rush. So get up, do some things, get on the Peloton, work out, take a shower, and then I always read um a chapter of a book. Wow. I'm hydrated, I've got half a gallon of water in me at this point in time. I can get a jump start on the day. I plan my day, I look at my priorities, I set my goals, do everything. And then I usually try to get, you know, get going on a project at like 7 a.m. Cause we start client meetings, sometimes eight o'clock, sometimes nine o'clock. So it gives me a couple runway while I'm fresh and clear. Um, but you know, at the end of the day, uh it makes me go to bed early, so I'm not in trouble. You know, like I, you know, I I just try really hard because for me, I just feel like I was given all these gifts and I need to hit my potential. And there's a lot of agencies that, you know, we want to grow, we want to be all professional services for independent agencies. And so if every year we grow 20, 25%, that's break pace growth, right? You break a lot of stuff when you build when you grow 20% every year.
SPEAKER_04Yeah.
SPEAKER_05You have to hire a lot of people, you have to redo your processes. Right. Like they need the best of me. And that just tends to keep me in alignment with what's best. So people are gonna be like, oh my gosh, I'm like, it's not for you. That's totally cool. I don't try to push my morning routine on everybody. But if I don't do it, I definitely don't feel right for the day.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Um, I am very similar to you. I'm a big routine guy. I get up usually around five o'clock. You say 3 45. Uh, more power to you. That's crazy. Um, but getting up at five, same deal. Like exercise and getting breakfast going. I'm just I guess I'm probably similar like you. I like my mind to be quiet in the morning and focus a little bit more on like slowly getting myself like, like you said, hydrated, moving, fed, caffeinated, like doing these things that slowly get you out of that deep. I'm a very deep sleeper. I always have been. And um congratulations. Yeah, thank you. I appreciate that. I'm very blessed. Uh, and by the time my uh almost seven-year-old daughter gets up, I'm like, boom, ready to go. I can take her to school five days a week. And same as you, as soon as I get back, usually around like eight o'clock, I'll I'm I get after it. And um I I think that's great that you shared that because there are so many people out there who don't like the mornings. And and here's what I encourage you have a nighttime routine.
SPEAKER_05I agree with that too.
SPEAKER_01Because if you don't like the mornings, then you probably like the night. So if you like the night, find a way to get yourself where you want to be before you go to bed.
SPEAKER_05I also just think that there's if I I mean, I don't have children, but I have I do fly every week. So like there's an inconsistency of like time zones and flights, and sometimes you're like, I have to keep something consistent. But I do think as adults with kids, um, like you have to find a way to have time just for yourself.
SPEAKER_01Yep. It's hard.
SPEAKER_05Like, you know, and it is hard. And it's whether it's, you know, but whether that's at night where you kind of just shut it down and the kids are asleep. But then I also think how you use that time is so critical, right? Like if you're gonna use it to watch The Bachelor, fine, if that's your way of doing it. But maybe if you instead worked out or took a walk or read a book, like would you go farther faster? But like that whole idea of doom scrolling, you know, like people just sit and like look at Instagram. I always just think, like, I, you know, I if I wasn't in business, I I I've often considered just ditching social media, like getting out of it, right? But it's a little hard. So now I'm like just very intentional. Like, and I'm even after like five minutes, I'm like, uh, okay.
SPEAKER_04Right, right.
SPEAKER_05Like I got, I don't know, I just have other things to do. I'd I'd rather be sleeping and resting than just like doing this. So but it's it's very easy for everybody to steal your time if you don't have an intention for it and you don't have boundaries on it too.
SPEAKER_01That's really great advice. Um biggest struggle is also another question we ask. Your biggest struggle you put was resistance to change. Um more specifically, like agencies not managing by performance and the difficulty getting clear metrics. Why has that specifically been a struggle for you?
SPEAKER_05All right. So, you know, you go into agencies and there's a um, you know, they're small businesses. So small businesses tend to be run a little differently than corporations, right, wrong, or indifferent. But what we find in a lot of agencies when they sign up with us, they're successful, they're growing, they can afford to have someone come in and work with their team, right? This is a certain size agency. But what you find is everybody's doing their own thing. Everyone's busy.
SPEAKER_00Right.
SPEAKER_05I'm like, okay, how much did we sell last month? We sold some stuff. Okay, how much did we retain? It was good. And then I'm like, okay, so then we we have a four-person data analytics team, right? So they start pulling the data and they do dashboards for our clients every week. And I'm like, okay, well, um, this is a hot mess. So like you sort of start growing, and then all of a sudden, like the water gets hotter and hotter and hotter. So now we have to come in and like these are unruly teenagers who everybody's been able to do whatever they want. There's been no goal, no target. If you cry, somebody will give you a raise. If you threaten to quit, somebody's gonna give you a raise. Um, or the owner's super generous and everybody has everything, right? Like there's you get to leave early on Friday and you get bonuses and you get this and you get that, and you get a car. And it's like, okay, everybody's so generous, but nobody's performing. And maybe they are performing, but there's no clarity on it. So you come in and then you have to confront what I call the Bev. So the first person I worked with insurance, her name was Bev, and she didn't trust computers. So we had to document in three places paper, paper file, notebook, carbon paper. Oh, old school.
SPEAKER_01And the glowing box where you tear off the tear off the dots on the side just to get the three copies.
SPEAKER_02Wait, carbon, glowing box? What was the third?
SPEAKER_05She had her own one that she collected every day. So Bev.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah, I'd like to get a beer with Bev. Yeah.
SPEAKER_05Yeah. You well, Bev was a tough, tough cookie, but um, but so like Bev isn't gonna change her ways. Like, so we come in and we're like, we need a procedure. What's our endorsement process? What's our new business process? So then we put it in and they don't want to do it. They don't want to do first call resolution, they don't want to do anything. So we have to evoke change from both the perspective the leaders have to start actually managing people for performance and adherence to strategy and not let everybody do what they want. So you can imagine that this is very challenging if you've been loyal to a company for 20, 25 years, and now we need to shift gears to have a procedure, right? So everybody's documenting and doing things accurately that they're like, oh, that's for new people. I'm like, no, no, it's for everybody.
SPEAKER_02Ellie, are you or I imagine you come in like you're the wicked witch of the West. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01What when are you going to Mooney Insurance brokers and raising?
SPEAKER_05I mean, it's been like I've been equated to like Jillian Michaels, uh, you know, bar the bar rescue guy, John Towns. I've been equated to Barton Ruffy, yeah.
SPEAKER_02Um but they must hate you. Like these employees are like cringing when they you're like the grim reaper walking through the room.
SPEAKER_05So we have a process. We have a process. So the first thing is we listen to them and we solve some really silly challenges, right? Like, yeah, okay, who do you report to? So we start doing that.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, right. Give me, give me the ease. What are the layups? What are the softballs? Bev also we reports to Bev.
SPEAKER_05Yeah. We also install our bonus plan. So they're like, ooh, we get more money. Yeah, you get more money. Cause it's you know accumulating based on book growth.
SPEAKER_04Yeah.
SPEAKER_05Um, and then we're kind of funny to them. Like we we listen, we are like bond with them and we paint the why, right? And you listen, 80% of the staff starts doing it, even if it takes a little while, right? Like they're they're trying. And the thing I say to agency owners, I say, okay, we know that your team's been doing this a long way. It's gonna take some time, but when would this become insubordination? Right. So there's a line, right? Like people who are trying are not insubordinate, but tell me how long until we've given them the tools, we've met with them, we've trained them, I've sat at their desk, you know, like we have given everything under their sun. They're just not doing this. And I remind agency owners, I'm not asking Beb to stand outside in a chicken costume with a sign that says buy insurance from us.
SPEAKER_04Right.
SPEAKER_05I'm asking them to document our system so everybody knows what's happening on the account, which is like ENO 101, right? So I'm not asking like for radical change up front. I'm asking for some pretty baseline things.
SPEAKER_02Right. And then they'll look at me.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, they all look at me like insubordination. When would it be insubordination?
SPEAKER_01Well, do you know what it is? Do you know what do you know what I feel like you're getting at? My interpretation of all that is accountability. It's like, when does your fuse run out on accountability? Like, does Bev have three months to attempt to change a 30-year-old habit, let's say, or does she have three years? Or is there no you're just gonna deal with Bev and say Bev is Bev? So I'm just gonna roll with that. But I think what's interesting uh about your approach and how you're doing it, one, I feel like you're coming in and you're being relatable. You're you're asking questions. Like everyone wants people to ask them questions because they people love to talk. So if you're like, hey, tell me about, tell me about how long have you been here and like you know, how's your day going? And what do you like to do for lunch? Maybe we'll go out there.
SPEAKER_04So busy. Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_01Oh god, I'm just so blah, blah. But it's like, I think being relatable is a great way to start knowing that you're driving toward accountability. Like your client is the agency owner, and the agency owner is struggling to keep all these people accountable, and you're like slapping the agency owner, you're like, look, you're either cool with Bev or you're not cool with Bev.
SPEAKER_05Maybe just senior, you know, but to really grow and to get scale and to get where you want everything to work frictionless, right? You have to have some of these conversations, and they're just a little overdue, right? Um, sometimes because agencies just grew through acquisitions or everything happened so fast. Sometimes it was the hard market and COVID. So we lost control a little bit. Um, sometimes it's just this fear of it's so hard to hire. You mean you hear this all the time. It's so hard to hire, so hard to hire. So I would say, what are you doing to hire? And they're like, uh a couple years ago we put a job posting on Indeed.
SPEAKER_01I'm like, okay, met a lot of interesting humans that way.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, like they were all garbage, all garbage. I'm like, so that was still a couple of years ago. What are we doing today? Well, you know, people don't, there's just no good people out there. I'm like, great. So then we have to build them. So we need to reorganize, have more entry-level roles, shift, scale, and then you can train people. Oh, well, there's no good people out there either. I'm like, well, then we should just sell our agency.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. I love she is she is John Taffer.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, there's no no excuses when you're gonna say Gordon Ramsay, Kelly doesn't take any trash.
SPEAKER_05Well, because it's it's like your own BS. And unfortunately in insurance, we have renewable revenue, which you guys don't have in real estate, right? You have some versions if you're renting at the properties or you have three peak customers, but not to the level we have here. So there's there's it it doesn't in in insurance, it really it like the hard market was the first time we got really hot really fast. For a lot of people, it's just a slow way like drive out, right? Like I could keep making the same amount of money. It's just that the it gets harder. So the friction points, the fighting, the annoyingness keeps getting louder and louder and louder. But I don't make any less money.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_02Kelly, what's your favorite part of your job? Or or do you have an agency that you're like, that was it? Like, like this one, I went in and it just went.
SPEAKER_05Oh, there's all sorts of those. But um, you know what I love? Uh, you know, our larger agencies goes what's called two-year program. So I love at the beginning, they're kind of held hostage by their team. There's no processes, they don't have clarity on their data, nobody's celebrating, nobody's winning. To the end, we're like who they thought was their best employee is now probably at the bottom half because we've helped them recruit and find the best people. The energy is different, the vibe is different. People are happy going to work. We're loving our customers. The processes have taken place. It's no longer new and choppy. And like the agency is hitting goals. Like, I share there's one agency that we have where I told them what we recommend a personalized sales goal to be if they were only selling. And they were like, What? That's impossible. And we got the right people in. You know, we did some recruiting from AAA. Put them into the right seats, and all of them are exceeding that goal. And I said, Yeah, it is possible. So I love the aha moments. I love the moments where the um we we stop running this community, like we're all gonna be equals to there is gonna be some hierarchy. And I know that might sound hard for people to understand, but for businesses to really grow, you need a leader, and there has to be someone calling the shots and having the performance and the accountability. So I love the end when they look at it like this was either this or selling, and now I see a long future that is gonna be amazing. And I'm like, great, my job is done. I John tapper it out.
SPEAKER_01That's right. All right, so that brings us to your quote. The quote that you provided us was clarity is kind. So why was that the quote you chose?
SPEAKER_05Yes. Can I go back to the last question real quick? Of course. Yeah. One thing just so there's one program that we have that's the hardest program that we do, um, which is our renewal review call program. So this is getting everybody in the agency to make an annual proactive renewal review out to every customer. Nobody thinks it can be done. But um, it 100% it it's people think of it as a service process. But if you do it, that's where you get your referrals, you get your coverage, your cross sells, your coverage increases. Um, you improve the product so customers know the discounts. Like we're proactively working those accounts, right? Um, and that just leads it solves every problem an agency has, your remarketing drops, all these things happen. Um, but nobody believes they can do it up front. And so it takes actually quite a lot of belief and exertion to get people into the rhythm of doing it. But I will say this we had two very large agencies that are national agencies. Um, the first one clocked in at 86% retention last July. By February, they were at 92%, which is massive. That is, they had over 30,000 policy renewals a month.
unknownWow.
SPEAKER_05So they were calling out to that not with VAs, not with AI, was straight like let's get it, get it going.
SPEAKER_02It's like almost half a million over the you know, yeah, a year.
SPEAKER_05Um the last the other one that just got we're about to finish it up, but they're about five months in. Um, they've bumped up in five months, so not nine, but five. So that will keep accelerating. Um, four points. So, like when I see those numbers at scale, not necessarily just in like your local retail shop, um, I say, you know, it's worth it to throw bodies at it, right? It's worth it to go do it. You just, you know, you can't just sit back. So those are the moments where it's like, it's so easy for me because I've seen it a million times, but to see it put into scale or is like, yeah.
SPEAKER_02Well, and two is you look at that bottom line. I mean, one point, two points is dramatic. You start getting into that territory on 30,000 a month. I mean, you're talking about big, big numbers.
SPEAKER_05I definitely paid for myself.
SPEAKER_02Oh, yeah. A couple of times away.
SPEAKER_05Yeah. But then they forget the fact that like the other uh like offshoot stat on that was um they ran that one agency, also ran a little mini contest to on cross sells from from the renewal calls. And they brought in another 112,000 in three weeks in revenue from cross-selling.
SPEAKER_04Wow.
SPEAKER_05So you know, it's like, hey, all I had to do is like, where do you have your auto?
SPEAKER_01Come on, Bev. Yeah, ask them where their auto is. One more question, Bev. Hey, hey, you have a pool. Put down the beer. That's the question.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, these are and by the way, I mean, the training's still new. They were only doing it for six months. So you can imagine, like, if they keep at it, they escalated the skill set that develops of overcoming those objections. So that you know, like it's like shooting shooting fish in a barrel, but getting agencies to understand the power of renewal review calls, they're always so hesitant to it.
SPEAKER_02And well, they're going in with one mindset, right? And and it's part of your job is you know, psych the psychiatrist or psychologist to kind of reformat, you know, why like why are we doing these? And to be able to explain to them, well, if you're doing this, it's more revenue, or make more revenue, you're making more money. You know what I mean? So I guess in a lot of ways, uh your um your training is is certainly consulting, but it there's this psychological uh aspect of it that comes with it.
SPEAKER_05But you gotta get the agency on or not think that Bev's gonna walk out because she's gotta call her customers. But Bev gives such good service because she's gonna tell you that I give great service.
SPEAKER_02Great service.
SPEAKER_05But what do you do? Would you do you call your customers a manual? Oh no, we don't have time for that.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_05There's a there's a little like that's what I'm talking about. There's there's no definition of excellence, right?
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_05Uh we had one agency a couple weeks ago that was like, we do a great job. We call customers back in three days.
SPEAKER_01Like wow fantastic work, amazing.
SPEAKER_05It's all perspective, you know. It's all amazing. Yeah, it's like that's what was it before?
SPEAKER_01Right, right, right. Three weeks. Yeah, three weeks, Kelly.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, but I diverge because I just had that like in the back of my head. Um, but the the favorite quote that you were saying, I think you did the Brene Brown one, is that right? The clarity is kind.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, clarity is kind, yep.
SPEAKER_05Yeah. So um there's another quote that I have that's like an offshoot of that, which someone once told me, which is the opposite of love is not hate, it's indifference. So, like in a marriage, if you almost stop arguing, it means you've given up and you're just like avoiding everything, right? Like it's just it's not worth my energy to do this, which is actually the worst sign for any relationship, right? So even if you take it into insurance or real estate, like if you have a team member that you just avoid, you don't want to talk to them. You're like, I'm just not even gonna address them to fix it. I just I can't. That's actually the worst sign, right? Because you've stopped caring about that person's development or next steps or, you know, almost like the rest of the team. So I always like to say the first step is we have to clarify like, what are the roles? What's your role? What's your responsibility? What are you gonna be measured by? What's the process? What's the strategy? Once you clarify, that's kind. But then the second half of it, it's the kindest thing you could do is communicate to somebody if they're not meeting expectation. So I like to say, Do you want to know if you have spinach in your teeth?
SPEAKER_02I do.
SPEAKER_05Everyone says that, but like the minute somebody tells you, you get really kind of nervous and embarrassed. How long has it been there?
SPEAKER_02No, I start to start digging. Like, oh here, I got it right.
SPEAKER_01I got it right here. Hey, flip, let me see that phone real quick. Yeah.
SPEAKER_05Yeah. But people get defensive, right? Like that's a normal human.
SPEAKER_01They feel like they're being judged.
SPEAKER_05So it's like, but it's also I try to tell people because um in insurance, a lot of people are service people and they just they have a lot of feelings. Like service people have just a lot of feelings.
SPEAKER_04Yeah.
SPEAKER_05Uh they just they like they're everywhere. Like they they just can't control them. So when you come to a service person and you tell them that, I always like to say, hey, you know, you're doing such a great job. I want to let you know this because I care about you, right? Because I care about your success. And I want to make sure that you understand clearly kind of where we're at and what needs to happen. It tends to go a little bit better. So I always just say clarity is kind. And um, in a lot of growing agencies, you're sort of winging it, working on chance, gut instinct, and your team needs clear direction. Like, what are we doing? Where are we going? What's the target? What's the goal? It can't change all the time. And you can't operate an agency like policy by client by client. Well, on this one we do this, on this one we do that. You'll never get to operational excellence.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Well, that is such awesome advice. What a great conversation. And uh, before we shut it down, Kelly, why don't you tell our watchers and listeners where they can learn more about you and everything you got going on with your business?
SPEAKER_05Yeah. So um agencyperformancepartners.com, you can go to YouTube. We have thousands of videos out there now. Or if you if you have any questions on insurance, go to our blog. Um, we have over a thousand blogs out there. We write blogs every week just on different challenges. So if you're searching, you can find it. Um, lots of people say we give so much away. You know, uh, you can get so many free resources on our website. But our job is to be the best friend to this industry. So if you want to reach out and learn more about how we can help your agency, happy to have that conversation. If you even want to just start by watching some of our videos or listen to our podcast, you can get a good vibe for what we do and and how we operate. But don't be scared of the John Tapper comment. He's always well liked at the end.
SPEAKER_01I love him. Right, they did. They all hug him at the end, right?
SPEAKER_05They're also happy with their newly renovated bar.
SPEAKER_01Exactly. Awesome. Well, hey, we greatly appreciate you sharing your time with us today. And that's all we have for this one, folks. Thank you for tuning in again to another episode of Bricks and Risk. See you next week. Thank you for joining us on another episode of Bricks and Risk. Our goal is that you walk away with one or two valuable nuggets, and we greatly appreciate you sharing your time with us today. You can find all BR episodes on Spotify, Apple Music, YouTube, and anywhere else to get your podcast content. Until next time, keep learning and keep growing.


