Kelly Donahue-Piro’s Proven Playbook: The Secret Weapon for Insurance Agencies in a Hard Market

Kelly Donahue-Piro, founder of Agency Performance Partners, shares how she helps independent insurance agencies thrive by focusing on three pillars: proactive retention, operational efficiency, and building a true sales experience. She addresses the challenges of the current hard market, including customer shopping, underwriting constraints, and “crispy” burned-out employees, while offering practical solutions like renewal review calls, save teams, and streamlined processes. Kelly emphasizes that strong leadership, accountability, and clarity are the keys to agency growth, culture renewal, and long-term success.

Table of contents

1. Introduction: why Kelly matters now

2. Who is Kelly Donahue-Piro and what is Agency Performance Partners?

3. The market landscape: a short primer (and why agencies must adapt)

4. The three strategic pillars Kelly teaches: Retention, Efficiency, Sales Experience

5. The “crispy employee” problem — burnout, underwriters, and the staffing gap

6. Renewal review calls: the single tactic that moves the needle (with results)

7. How Kelly restructures agencies: practical, repeatable playbooks

8. Quick operational checklist: 12 things to get efficient fast

9. Table: Industry indicators & program ROI (snapshot)

10. Real leadership moves: accountability + culture = growth

11. SEO takeaways for independent agencies (how to show up and be found)

12. FAQ — common questions answered

13. Resources & two recent articles to read next

1. Introduction: why Kelly matters now

If you run or advise an independent insurance agency in 2024–2025, you’re living in a market that is one part volatility, one part opportunity. Leaders who double down on retention, tighten operations, and build repeatable sales experiences will win. Kelly Donahue-Piro has made a career out of turning those strategic ideas into measurable results for agencies across the U.S. and Canada. Her approach is practical, no-nonsense, and built around one central belief: clarity is kind — when teams know what’s expected, performance improves and culture heals.

2. Who is Kelly Donahue-Piro and what is Agency Performance Partners?

Kelly Donahue-Piro is the founder and president of Agency Performance Partners (APP). She built APP to be a consulting and training firm focused exclusively on helping independent insurance agencies become more profitable, repeatable, and people-first. Kelly’s background includes a degree in relationship marketing (Bentley University) and executive roles in insurance marketing and client services before launching APP in 2014. APP positions itself as the pragmatic “BFF” to agency owners — a blend of coaching, benchmarking, sales training, and operational redesign. Kelly’s specialties include upselling, retention strategy, sales scripting, agency culture change, executive coaching, and benchmarking.

Why this matters: Kelly doesn’t sell airy strategy. She designs programs (renewal review campaigns, performance dashboards, hiring frameworks) that agencies can implement and measure. That focus on measurable results is why agencies who commit to APP’s programs report major improvements in retention and cross-sell revenue.

3. The market landscape: a short primer (and why agencies must adapt)

The last several years created a “hard market” dynamic in many lines: elevated premiums, tighter underwriting, and more onerous eligibility checks. Reinsurance capacity tightened, carriers narrowed appetites, and underwriting became far less forgiving — all of which increased friction for agencies and their customers. Industry analysts have documented this hardening and its partial moderation as new capacity returned in some lines. Insurance Journal

At the same time, pockets of the market are already showing signs of easing. Major carriers and market commentators reported that auto insurance pricing has begun to calm after steep increases, with some filings showing modest rate reductions in specific states. This uneven softening creates a crucial moment: when rates stabilize or decline, many carriers and competitors will actively attack books that haven’t been defended through proactive retention and sales work. (See recent industry coverage on price moderation and Florida rate movement.) WJXT

Takeaway: the market will not simply “go back” to 2019. There will be winners and losers. Agencies that prepare through retention programs, streamlined operations, and strengthened sales processes will keep more customers and capture growth when carriers loosen appetite.

4. The three strategic pillars Kelly teaches: Retention, Efficiency, Sales Experience

Kelly organizes agency response into three practical pillars:

Pillar 1 — Retention: proactively earn renewals

Retention is not “automatic.” Kelly emphasizes that agencies must earn renewal commissions through proactive outreach (renewal reviews), cross-selling, and educating customers — especially when rates begin to stabilize and competitors start marketing aggressively. Without a retention playbook, agencies will lose customers they could have kept.

Pillar 2 — Efficiency & effectiveness: do more with clarity

Many agencies are bloated in process and inconsistent in execution. Kelly coaches agencies to remove process waste, lean on technology for repeatable tasks, and — where necessary — “fire” the bottom 10–15% of customers who drain service capacity. Efficiency frees bandwidth for high-value retention and sales work.

Pillar 3 — Sales experience: make quoting a conversion machine

Agencies often have quoting systems without a sales experience. Kelly builds repeatable sales flows, scripting, and KPIs to ensure that every new business opportunity becomes a platform for cross-sell and long-term value — not just a one-time mono-line quote.

5. The “crispy employee” problem — burnout, underwriters, and the staffing gap

Kelly’s interview uses the vivid phrase “crispy” for front-line staff: burned out, exhausted from tough conversations, and unable to sustain the emotional labor required in a hard market. Two structural forces amplify the problem:

• Underwriter constraints & turnover: Underwriters faced with stricter guidelines and fewer exceptions have less latitude to help agencies — and there’s also an experience gap as veteran staff retire or leave. That reduces service levels and lengthens response times. DefaultAon

• Workforce shortage & retirement: The industry is experiencing a talent crunch and mass retirements that amplify staffing pressure across carriers and agencies. Recent industry reporting highlights a growing talent gap and frontline exhaustion across insurance sectors. Insurance Journal

Kelly’s prescription: rebuild staff confidence through focused training, create “save teams” (salespeople or specialists incentivized to rescue cancellations), and set up clear performance management so teams can perform without being ground down.

6. Renewal review calls: the single tactic that moves the needle (with results)

Kelly talks about one tactical program again and again: the proactive renewal review call. The program’s goal is simple: annually contact every customer to review coverages, find cross-sell opportunities, fix gaps, and re-establish trust.

Why it works:

• Customers feel engaged and informed (reducing the impulse to shop).

• Agents discover cross-sell opportunities (homes with pools, autos, umbrella needs).

• Agencies can correct eligibility or underwriting errors before they become crises.

Concrete results Kelly shares from APP programs:

• A large national agency moved from 86% retention to 92% retention over a renewal program span (30,000 policy renewals monthly). Kelly credits proactive human outreach for that improvement and points to rapid, measurable ROI.

Kelly emphasizes that this is not an “AI trick” or a light touch — it’s people making intentional renewal calls, running contests, and measuring outcomes. The short-term lift in retention and cross-sell revenue often pays for the program several times over.

7. How Kelly restructures agencies: practical, repeatable playbooks

Kelly’s work with agencies tends to follow a repeatable path:

1. Audit & clarity: map existing processes (new business, endorsements, renewals), identify bottlenecks, and set measurable KPIs. She frequently uses contactable dashboards and weekly scorecards to make performance visible.

2. Reorganize roles: define entry-level and specialty seats so talent can grow, and so owners stop trying to hire “perfect talent” and instead can train and retain.

3. Renewal program design: roll out renewal reviews with scripts, playbooks, and measurable targets. Incentivize staff with weekly bonus plans tied to cross-sell and retention metrics.

4. Leadership coaching: get owners comfortable with performance conversations — sometimes the hardest change is moving from “nice boss” to “clear leader.” Kelly’s phrase: “clarity is kind” — telling people where they stand is a form of caring that enables growth.

8. Quick operational checklist: 12 things to get efficient fast

Kelly says there are approximately a dozen operational levers agencies commonly miss. Here’s a condensed checklist you can start with today:

1. Map new-business and renewal workflows end-to-end.

2. Implement weekly dashboards for sales, retention, and endorsements.

3. Introduce first-call resolution targets and headset/tech upgrades.

4. Build a renewal review cadence (assign owners & scripts).

5. Put a 90-day onboarding and training plan for new hires.

6. Identify bottom 10–15% of unprofitable accounts for remediation or off-boarding.

7. Create an incentive program tied to cross-sell and retention metrics.

8. Train a “save team” to manage cancellations and holdbacks.

9. Audit vendor/inspection quality (to avoid mistakes that cause non-renewals).

10. Run monthly leadership huddles to reinforce expectations.

11. Use simple CRM tags to route accounts for cross-sell prompts.

12. Measure EVERYTHING — you can’t fix what you don’t measure.

9. Table: Industry indicators & program ROI (snapshot)

10. Real leadership moves: accountability + culture = growth

A central theme in Kelly’s work is that clarity is kind. That phrase is an operating principle: define roles, set targets, measure performance, and have the tough conversations when expectations aren’t met. Those conversations aren’t cruel — they create predictability and fairness for the whole team. Kelly’s field experience shows that once an agency accepts this shift, energy improves, service improves, and growth follows — sometimes quickly.

Examples of leadership moves Kelly recommends:

• Move from “everyone does everything” to defined roles with KPIs.

• Stop tolerating chronic process non-adherence; provide tools, training, then hold accountable.

• Run short contests tied to retention and cross-sell during renewal waves — gamification works.

11. SEO takeaways for independent agencies (how to show up and be found)

If your larger goal is to attract new customers as well as keep the old ones, a modern agency needs a content and local SEO plan:

• Publish helpful renewal education and coverage explainer pages (these will rank for “homeowner renewal checklist,” “what is dwelling coverage,” etc.).

• Create short video snippets of renewal review conversations (with privacy safeguards) and promote them on YouTube and social.

• Ask satisfied clients for Google reviews after positive renewal reviews — reviews influence local search.

• Use targeted landing pages for high-value cross-sell keywords (e.g., “umbrella insurance [city]”).

Kelly’s own firm publishes a large library of blogs and videos to help agencies — and she encourages agencies to give value away first. That approach builds trust and search relevance over time.

12. FAQ — common questions readers will search for

Q1: What is a renewal review call and why does it matter?
A: A renewal review call is a proactive, scheduled conversation at policy renewal designed to confirm coverage, find cross-sell opportunities, and address client concerns. Kelly’s programs show significant retention improvements when performed at scale.

Q2: How much lift can an agency expect from a renewal program?
A: Results vary by baseline, but APP cites real examples where retention moved from 86% to 92% across large renewal volumes — a difference that can equal hundreds of thousands of dollars in retained premium.

Q3: My team is burned out. Where do I start?
A: Start by auditing workloads, identifying “time-draining” customers (the bottom 10–15%), and introducing targeted training plus a “save team” to remove repetitive cancellation stress from service staff.

Q4: Should I fire unprofitable customers?
A: Not immediately — first quantify their cost to serve, attempt remediation, and then make selective decisions. Kelly recommends freeing up capacity by off-boarding the smallest, most resource-consuming accounts after attempts at remediation.

Q5: How do I measure ROI on retention programs?
A: Track retention rate, cross-sell revenue, cost per outbound call, and churned premium avoided. Simple dashboards showing month-over-month trends are critical. Kelly’s clients use weekly dashboards to measure progress.

Q6: Where can I learn more about implementing Kelly’s methods?
A: Agency Performance Partners offers blogs, videos, and coaching engagements. Start with APP’s library or contact them for a program assessment.

13. Resources & two recent articles to read next

If you want context on the market and why Kelly’s focus on retention and operations is so timely, read these recent coverage pieces:

• Reuters — International, domestic insurers push into catastrophe-hit US property markets (analysis of carrier appetite and the E&S market). Reuters

• Barron’s — Auto Insurance Rates Are Calming Down. What It Means for Geico, Progressive Earnings. (analysis of auto pricing moderation and carrier actions). Barron's

Both pieces help explain the market forces Kelly is addressing: underwriting tightening, shifting carrier appetites, and the window of opportunity as pricing stabilizes.

Closing: the leader’s action plan (do these 5 things this week)

1. Pick one renewal segment (e.g., homeowners with >2 policies) and run a 30-day renewal review pilot. Measure calls, cross-sell attempts, and retention.

2. Run a 60-minute leadership huddle: agree on 3 KPIs to measure weekly (retention %, call count, cross-sell $).

3. Identify the bottom 10% of accounts by cost-to-serve and make a remediation plan.

4. Create a “save team” script and a small incentive for cancellations kept.

5. Start documenting one broken process (endorsements or new business) and map a new, simpler workflow.

Where can you find out more about Kelly Donahue-Piro?

Web: https://www.agencyperformancepartners.com/meet-kelly/
YouTube: www.youtube.com/@InsuranceAgencyConsulting
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/appsinsurance/
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/agencyperformancepartners
LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/agency-performance-partners
Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/6uj5wqcZo0n4e5v8FfzwNw?si=7edcf506fa6e49de
Blog: https://www.agencyperformancepartners.com/blog/

📲 Want more inspiration, insights, and expert advice at the intersection of real estate, insurance, and entrepreneurship?

Connect with Bricks and Risk here:
🌐 Web: https://bricksandrisk.com/
🔗 YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@BricksandRisk
📸 Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/bricksandrisk/
📘 Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/bricksandrisk
💼 LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/bricksandrisk/