Table of Contents
Introduction
Buying a home with a real estate professional or choosing an insurance provider —these decisions aren’t just transactional. They're deeply personal, risky, and often expensive. In a world oversaturated with advertising and SEO-optimized company pages, how do everyday people actually make these decisions?
That’s exactly what we explored in a recent Bricks and Risk podcast episode—a candid conversation that unearthed the real, unscripted vetting processes people use when choosing professionals in real estate and insurance.
Why Referrals Still Rule in 2025
Despite the rise of flashy websites and digital marketing, word-of-mouth referrals remain the gold standard for vetting agents, brokers, and service providers.
“I always start by asking someone I know—someone who went through a similar process, in a similar area, with a similar budget,” one guest shared.
This approach reflects an essential truth: relevance and relatability build trust. If someone in your circle had a smooth homebuying experience under the same conditions, that agent becomes infinitely more credible than the top result on Google.
Cold Outreach: A Modern Twist on Vetting
While referrals are king, some are willing to take things a step further. One guest discussed how he reached out cold to a homeowner who had recently completed a custom home build in the area he was considering.
“I found the builder’s name, pulled the court documents, tracked down the owner, and emailed him asking what the build process was like.”
This direct, boots-on-the-ground research provided insights that no online review could offer—like township difficulties, builder hiccups, and what to expect during a custom build. The takeaway? Don’t be afraid to reach out directly to real people.
The Real Value of a Real Estate Agent
There’s a common misconception that agents simply “open doors and fill out paperwork.” But this view minimizes the experience, strategy, and market knowledge that seasoned agents bring to the table.
The FSBO Trap
A growing number of sellers try to avoid commissions by going For Sale By Owner (FSBO). But the data tells a different story.
“We had a seller call and say, ‘It’s a hot market—I’m not using an agent.’ But the reality is that FSBOs often leave money on the table.”
The Myth of Exclusive Listings
Some brokerages advertise “exclusive listings” not on the MLS, giving the illusion of VIP access. However:
90% of exclusive listings end up on the MLS anyway, meaning the seller often defaults to a more traditional path.
Only a small fraction—perhaps 2–3%—remain truly exclusive, often for luxury properties.
🔗 For more insights on the benefits of using an agent, visit NAR’s Research & Statistics and Zillow’s Real Estate Advice.
Insurance Shopping: Trust, Price, and Service
Insurance is another space where consumers often feel overwhelmed or price-driven. But the conversation revealed some smarter vetting techniques:
Start with a personal network.
If no referrals exist, Google is next—but skip the ads.
Pay attention to service quality.
Get multiple quotes.
The guest noted:
“If I don’t know someone, I’ll search for homeowners insurance in my area, ignore the paid ads, and look at the top organic results.”
But even then, there's a catch: some companies that rank high have dozens of agents, many of whom are inexperienced. Consumers are ultimately judging:
Service quality
Communication style
Trustworthiness
Cost
How Facebook Groups Became the New Yelp
For hyper-local services like contractors, electricians, or fence installers—especially in second-home areas like the Jersey Shore—Facebook groups are the new go-to.
By searching inside local community groups, users can:
See past recommendations from residents.
Find contractors with specific experience for their exact project.
Avoid the pay-to-play nature of traditional Google searches.
“If someone says they had vinyl fencing installed around a full perimeter—exactly what I need—now I’ve got a name, a testimonial, and local credibility.”
This strategy adds another layer of social proof and avoids the guesswork of generic review sites.
Comparative Table: FSBO vs. Agent-Assisted Sales
Here's a breakdown of why professional help often wins out:
Category | FSBO (For Sale By Owner) | Agent-Assisted Sale |
|---|---|---|
Listing Exposure | Limited (No MLS unless paid separately) | Full exposure (MLS, social, email) |
Sale Price | Typically lower | Often 6–13% higher (NAR, 2024) |
Time on Market | Longer (avg. 3–6 weeks more) | Faster due to proactive strategy |
Legal Support | Must hire a lawyer separately | Included in agent’s scope |
Negotiation Expertise | Limited unless experienced | Professional-level negotiation |
Buyer Screening | DIY (often weak) | Pre-qualified and vetted |
Stress Level | High | Lower with proper agent guidance |
📊 Source: National Association of Realtors (2024), Zillow Consumer Housing Trends Report
Conclusion
In a landscape saturated with SEO, branding, and marketing fluff, the way real people vet professionals hasn’t changed all that much: we still trust people over platforms.
Whether you’re looking to build, buy, insure, or improve—referrals, transparency, and hands-on research still reign supreme. However, new tools like Facebook groups, local forums, and strategic online searches add power to the process—when used thoughtfully.
Key Takeaways:
Start with real, relatable referrals.
Don’t be afraid to cold outreach for real insight.
Know that agents do more than just "open doors."
Insurance is not just a price game—service matters.
Local Facebook groups can surface the best contractors and vendors.
FAQs
Q1: Is it worth using a real estate agent in a hot market?
Yes. Even in a hot market, agents provide negotiation skills, market insight, and MLS access that often lead to higher sale prices and smoother transactions.
Q2: What’s the risk of FSBO (For Sale By Owner)?
Most FSBO homes sell for less and spend more time on the market. According to NAR, 60–70% of FSBO listings end up switching to agent representation.
Q3: How can I find a trustworthy insurance agent?
Start with referrals. If none exist, search online—but be wary of paid ads. Focus on customer reviews, service quality, and agent responsiveness.
Q4: Why are Facebook groups useful for finding contractors?
They offer firsthand experiences from locals. If someone just had similar work done, you gain insight and can vet results before reaching out.
Q5: What’s the problem with exclusive listings?
They're often marketing tactics that still end up on the MLS. Only a small percentage remain truly exclusive, typically in the luxury property segment.
📲 Want more inspiration, insights, and expert advice at the intersection of real estate, insurance, and entrepreneurship?
Connect with Bricks and Risk here:
🌐 Web: https://bricksandrisk.com/
🔗 YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@BricksandRisk
📸 Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/bricksandrisk/
📘 Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/bricksandrisk
💼 LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/bricksandrisk