Meta Ads for Ecommerce: Horn & Hardart CEO’s Playbook  #metaads  #digitalmarketing
Bricks & Risk PodcastOctober 21, 202600:00:39

Meta Ads for Ecommerce: Horn & Hardart CEO’s Playbook #metaads #digitalmarketing

Horn & Hardart CEO Dave Arena explains how Meta ads became the top driver of new customers for his ecommerce brand and how they keep refining them.

What does it take to get a legendary brand back in front of people who haven’t thought about it in decades? For Dave Arena, the CEO of Horn & Hardart, a big part of the answer is paid advertising, and in this clip from Bricks and Risk Episode 147 he walks us through how it works. Meta ads, the ads you see on Facebook and Instagram, have been the number one driver of new business for the Horn & Hardart ecommerce brand. It isn’t a one-time win either. It’s something Dave and his team keep working on, and they are now looking at how to replicate that success on other platforms.

That detail matters. Plenty of business owners find one thing that works and then ride it until it stops. Dave describes the opposite habit. Paid ads are not a set-it-and-forget-it channel for @hornandhardart They are tested, tweaked, and measured constantly, because the cost of acquiring a customer can move quickly in either direction. He’s candid about it, too. A number that looks fine one month can feel painfully high the next, and the only way to stay ahead is to keep paying attention to what the data is telling you.

The numbers show why he stays on it. Dave shared that coffee brands typically pay somewhere between thirty and fifty dollars to bring in a single new customer. Horn & Hardart has been paying around eleven. He credits the history of the brand for much of that gap. Millions of people already remember Horn & Hardart, so an ad doesn’t have to introduce them to something new. It has to remind them of something they already feel good about. The challenge is that many of those same people don’t know the brand is back, and a well-placed ad is how you tell them.

Paid ads also give a small business something that’s hard to get any other way, which is information. Horn & Hardart ships to all 50 states, and Dave says they know where their customers are down to the zip code. That kind of insight shapes decisions about where to focus marketing and, eventually, where an Automat might make sense. It’s a good reminder that marketing is not only about getting attention. It’s about learning who is paying attention and why.

If you work in real estate or insurance, there is a lot to take from this. Lead generation is the lifeblood of both businesses, and paid social is one of the tools many agents and producers either avoid or try once and abandon. Dave’s approach is a model for doing it with discipline: pick a platform, learn it deeply, track what each customer costs you, and keep improving the message before you try to be everywhere. Once one channel is working, then you look at how to carry what you learned to the next one, which is exactly what Horn & Hardart is doing now.

If you are a consumer or a future founder, this clip pulls back the curtain on something you see every day. The ad that showed up on your phone about a coffee brand you half remember from your grandparents’ stories didn’t land there by accident. It’s the result of a small team watching numbers, testing ideas, and trying to earn your attention in a crowded feed. And behind it is a small team trying to rebuild something that people still care about.

It’s also worth knowing who is doing the work. Dave’s wife, Kim, is the company’s COO and runs marketing, even though she didn’t come from a marketing background. She learned it by doing it, and that’s an encouraging thought for anyone who feels they need a title or a degree before they can run their own ads. You don’t. You need curiosity, a willingness to test, and the patience to let the numbers teach you what your instincts can’t.

The takeaway is simple and hard at the same time. Marketing is not a magic trick. It’s a loop of testing, learning, and refining, done by people who are willing to look at their results honestly. Dave doesn’t pretend to have it all solved, and he says openly that reaching a younger audience for the cold brew is a challenge they are still testing their way through. That honesty is part of why his numbers look the way they do.
Horn & Hardart, Horn Hardart, Hornandhardart, Horn and Hardart automat,