TLDR:
Homeowners are being misled by viral advice that says to “file every claim,” but in today’s insurance market, small claims can trigger rate hikes, inspections, and long-term financial consequences. In this episode, Tim and Sean break down why filing isn’t always the smart move, how carriers actually evaluate claims, and why a simple 3-step framework—get an estimate, call your agent, and assess the 360° impact—protects you far better than filing on autopilot. Before you make your next insurance decision, this conversation might save you money, frustration, and your future insurability.
Table of Contents
Why Filing a Claim Isn’t as Simple as You Think
The Viral “File Everything” Advice — and Why It’s Dangerous
Understanding How Claims Really Affect Your Premiums
The Hidden Costs of “Shopping Around” After a Rate Increase
How Independent Agents Can Save You From Expensive Mistakes
The Three-Step Decision Framework Every Homeowner Should Follow
Real-World Stories That Reveal the Truth About Claims
Final Thoughts: Think Strategically, Not Emotionally
FAQ
Why Filing a Claim Isn’t as Simple as You Think
Homeowners pay premiums for peace of mind. So it feels natural to assume: If something breaks or gets damaged, the insurance company should pay for it.
But today’s insurance landscape isn’t the one you grew up with. Premiums are rising faster than inflation, carriers are tightening underwriting standards, and claims—even small ones—can follow you for years. That means homeowners must think like strategists, not just policyholders.
In our latest Bricks and Risk episode, we broke down a viral LinkedIn post telling homeowners to “file every claim.” It was catchy, shareable, and confidently stated. But it was also dangerous. Because if you follow that advice blindly, you could end up paying far more in the long run.
Let’s break down the truth.
The Viral “File Everything” Advice — and Why It’s Dangerous
The LinkedIn post in question wasn’t written by an insurance professional. It was written by an attorney who insisted that homeowners should “file, file, file”—for everything from a shingle on the lawn to nail pops in the drywall.
It makes for a bold soundbite.
It makes for terrible financial advice.
Here’s why that narrative is flawed:
1. Not every loss is worth filing.
If the repair is $600 and your deductible is $1,000, you’re getting a $0 payout—but you still just recorded a claim. That claim follows you for years.
2. Claims don’t “keep the system honest.”
There is no centralized “system” that balances itself based on small claims. Insurance carriers don’t adjust pricing strategies because of micro-level homeowner behavior.
This was one of the most misleading parts of that viral post.
3. Attorneys have different motivations than insurance professionals.
Attorneys think in terms of disputes and payouts.
Agents think in terms of long-term financial health, insurability, and renewal trajectories.
Filing a claim is a financial decision—not a moral one.
Understanding How Claims Really Affect Your Premiums
This is where homeowners get tripped up.
A large claim (e.g., $10K–$50K) often makes financial sense to file. The payout drastically outweighs the future premium impact.
But small and mid-sized claims? That’s where the trouble starts.
A claim triggers several kinds of consequences:
Loss of claim-free discounts
Renewal increases (which often last 3+ years)
Higher deductibles at renewal
Limited ability to switch carriers later
Potential inspections that uncover more required repairs
And if you've already had a couple of claims—even minor ones—your next filing could push your carrier to non-renew your policy entirely.
To better understand why claim decisions matter so much, consumer research clearly shows that premiums are rising significantly across the country. Homeowners are already seeing historic increases in 2024–2025—meaning the impact of a claim is magnified.
A recent J.D. Power Home Insurance Study highlights just how dramatically these increases have reshaped customer behavior and satisfaction.
👉 Source: https://www.jdpower.com/business/home-insurance/2024-us-home-insurance-study
The Hidden Costs of “Shopping Around” After a Rate Increase
The viral LinkedIn advice also said: “If your rate goes up, just shop around.”
Sure—you can shop around.
But you may not like what you find.
Here’s what people don’t realize:
1. Every new carrier sends an inspector.
Whether it’s a drive-by, drone, or in-person assessment, inspections are non-negotiable.
2. Inspections reveal issues your old carrier missed.
Examples include:
Cracked sidewalks
A non-compliant pool fence
Old roofs
Dead trees
Improper wiring
Missing handrails
Suddenly, your “cheap new quote” becomes:
A repairs list
plusA revised premium that’s higher than the original
3. Some carriers intentionally lowball first-year pricing.
They use introductory pricing to acquire new customers, then take significant rate increases at renewal.
This tactic is well documented in consumer insurance reporting and watchdog analyses.
4. In severe cases, you can get canceled before the policy even starts.
Nothing is worse than switching carriers only to find out your home is uninsurable after the underwriting inspection.
To reinforce how claims influence premiums—and why shopping at the wrong time is risky—Bankrate’s nationally recognized consumer guide provides an excellent breakdown of why claims raise rates and how to think strategically.
👉 Source: https://www.bankrate.com/insurance/homeowners-insurance/why-file-a-claim/
How Independent Agents Can Save You From Expensive Mistakes
This is one of the clearest takeaways from our conversation.
Independent agents:
Represent multiple carriers
Know underwriting rules
Understand inspection triggers
Can pre-screen carriers for compatibility
Can protect you from stepping into an underwriting trap
Captive/big-box carriers can only sell what they offer. Independent agents can look across the market and say:
“Carrier A won’t like your roof.
Carrier B won’t like the pool.
Carrier C is your best fit—and here’s why.”
This consultative guidance is priceless in a market with rising rates and strict underwriting.
The Three-Step Decision Framework Every Homeowner Should Follow
After reviewing the transcript and distilling our conversation, here is the clearest, simplest, and most powerful framework a homeowner can use.
Step 1: Get a Professional Estimate
Before calling your insurance company—ever—get a written estimate from a licensed contractor.
Why?
You need hard numbers.
Your agent needs hard numbers.
Without them, you’re guessing—and guessing leads to unnecessary claims.
This prevents the classic mistake:
Filing a claim that results in $0 paid out.
Step 2: Call Your Agent (Not the Carrier Hotline)
Your agent can:
Assess coverage
Review policy details
Break down whether the claim is worthwhile
Estimate the future impact
Compare the damage to your deductible
Review your recent claim history
A good agent gives advice like they would give to their own family.
If your agent can’t or won’t?
You need a new agent.
Step 3: Evaluate the Situation from All Angles (The 360° Check)
Consider:
The size of the loss
Your deductible
Expected payout
Renewal impact
Long-term insurability
Whether switching carriers will become harder
Whether filing will force repairs you were not planning to make
Too many homeowners only consider:
“Is the loss higher than my deductible?”
That’s only one factor.
A real claim decision requires looking at all seven.
Real-World Stories That Reveal the Truth About Claims
The transcript gave us several great examples. Each illustrates a principle.
1. The Condo Roof Leak
A minor water stain triggered a claim—but the payout was minimal.
Today, that same claim would likely be considered “not worth it.”
Lesson: Cosmetic or minor damage rarely justifies a claim.
2. The Philly Street Mirror Smash
A knocked-off car mirror is technically covered.
But should you file?
Depends on deductible vs. cost.
Lesson: Urban living comes with frequent small losses—not all should be claims.
3. The $150 DIY Car Door
One co-host hunted down a used car door in a salvage yard to avoid a claim.
It was inconvenient.
It was time-consuming.
It was absolutely the right financial call.
Lesson: Sometimes you swallow your pride to protect your premium.
Final Thoughts: Think Strategically, Not Emotionally
Homeowners often make decisions emotionally:
“I pay for insurance—I want to use it.”
“This isn’t fair.”
“This feels like the carrier should pay.”
But insurance is a financial tool.
A strategic tool.
A long-term tool.
Your goal is to protect:
Your home
Your wallet
Your future insurability
Your ability to switch carriers
Your renewal rates
Use claims wisely, not reactively.
FAQ
Q: How do I know if a claim is “worth it”?
Compare the repair cost, deductible, and likely premium impact. Your agent can help calculate this.
Q: Will one small claim raise my rates?
Often yes. It depends on the claim type, carrier, and your recent history. Many carriers increase premiums for 3–5 years after a claim.
Q: Do insurance companies share claim history?
Yes. Claims are stored in industry databases accessible to other carriers when you shop for new coverage.
Q: Should I shop around every year?
You can, but shop strategically. Rate increases are normal right now. Make sure you understand inspection requirements before switching.
Q: What if my claim gets denied?
Ask the carrier to clarify the basis. If you disagree, your agent can help you appeal or provide additional documentation.
Q: Is it true that every claim stays on your record for years?
Yes—many carriers look at 3–5 years of claim history when determining eligibility and pricing.
Q: Should I file a claim for cosmetic damage?
Generally, no. Cosmetic damage rarely exceeds deductibles and often triggers rate increases without meaningful payout.
Q: What’s the best first step after damage occurs?
Always: get a professional estimate. You need real numbers to make an informed decision.
📲 Want more inspiration, insights, and expert advice at the intersection of real estate, insurance, and entrepreneurship?
Connect with Bricks and Risk here:
🌐 Web: https://bricksandrisk.com/
🔗 YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@BricksandRisk
📸 Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/bricksandrisk/
📘 Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/bricksandrisk
💼 LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/bricksandrisk